A Computer hardware and components forum. ComputerBanter.com

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » ComputerBanter.com forum » Video Cards » Nvidia Videocards
Site Map Home Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Linux user: please support hardware vendors whith good Linux suppor.



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old December 28th 05, 01:12 AM posted to alt.comp.periphs.videocards.nvidia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Linux user: please support hardware vendors whith good Linux suppor.

This is a repost: Original post on alt.os.linux.suse
Subject: SUSE 10.0 NVIDIA: how to enable 3D -- temporary conclusions --
==
I think the Linux support on Nvidia, is at best poor: hard to install, often
instable.

Also the Nvidia Linux drivers distribution model is unacceptable: I still
consider that when I purchase a computer peripheral for Linux, then I
should be able to use clean open source drivers for it.

I have purchased several NVIDIA cards, but unless NVIDIA wakes up and
provides a good alternative to the current situation... which has lasted a
long time, I will try ATI (or other video cards/chip vendor) in the future,
hoping that the situation is better there. (Not sure).

It is interesting to note that often new vendors establish a solid presence
in the Linux (and other open source)by providing what is missing.
I am wondering how many Laser printers did sell on the Linux market...
because others printers vendors had poor linux support.
My guess is "a lot ".

note: freely providing the technical product specification, API (application
programming interface) specification is what the open source guys need to
write device drivers.
Reverse engineering is possible, of course... but painful.
==
AnonymousFC4 wrote:

Hello:
boy, did I strike a cord with this posting !

my conclusions:

1) Other people seem to have similar issue, so it is real.

2) Since I downgraded the kernel, (to 2.6.13.5) I did not have a single
crash crash... and they where very frequent.
I did not enable 3D (but I did with SUSE 10 RC3 and had zero problems!

3) The kernel 2.6.13.5.7 may be OK but combined with the NVIDIA driver
there is a visible problem! Since we do not have access to the source code
of the driver, proper identitification is possible, but trickier.

4) I mildly disagree with the accusations of SUSE being lower quality,
SUSE 10.0 is overall excellent... but I would agree and reiterate that
SUSE/NOVELL should more focused on quality and testing, than only eyes
candy and marketing driven cosmetics "a la Microsoft".

Linux is supposed to be about substance, and the distro vendors will do
well to add value to Linux the smart way: add what is missing... like the
RPM manager (Red-Hat) or YAST (SUSE)... or trainings, documentation that
the hobbyists developing Linux don't care for.

5) The new business model (Open SUSE)is a good one, similar to Fedora, but
it fails on one point: proper integration and test of NON-GPL software
like NVIDIA device drivers, etc...

This should be easy to fix if SUSE does the proper "lobbying" to test and
release candidate of SUSE Linux, WITH THE INCLUSION of the non-gpl stuff!.
This includes ACROREAD, MP3 modules, etc....
Also large companies like NVIDIA could allow propre creations of distro
specific RPM's by releasing the "building blocks" even in some compiled
form, they also should amend their user's license to allow free
distribution!

We (users) should vote with our wallet by preferrately purchasing hardware
(here video cards) with open source software drivers...
How will NVIDIA, ATI and chip vendors achieve this? This is up to them!
There are many possible options.

6) The RTFM claim made here, by one posting has some validity... and some
sillyness in it: if I wanted to get in this mode, why should I use SUSE,
or RedHat, I will rather go Debian or derivatives (UBUNTU, possibly).

I have chosen SUSE Linux because I want to be user, not a hacker: my
expectation with it being a Linux Distro well documented, and simple to
use/update.
I would expect SUSE/NOVEL to make money by selling packages (less and
less), but books, training, and sopport.

7) The kids are still nagging...
At some point the kids will grow up and contribute, I am sure.

Thanks for all the posting, and contributions...
AFC4
====================
Roy L. Fuchs wrote:
On Sun, 25 Dec 2005 06:35:09 GMT, Andreas Gave
us: Roy L. Fuchs escribe:
If YOU would learn to READ the SUSE Linux Install HOW-TO on the
NVIDIA website, you would LEARN that the problem is YOU.
YOU as in [Y]ast [O]nline [u]pdate?

Wrong. "YOU" as in the person that posted the supposed "problem".


  #2  
Old December 28th 05, 05:12 AM posted to alt.comp.periphs.videocards.nvidia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Linux user: please support hardware vendors whith good Linux suppor.

All right, please identify a video board vendor with good Linux support.
You don't like nvidia's model, ATI's is the same, where does that leave
you?

AnonymousFC4 wrote:

This is a repost: Original post on alt.os.linux.suse
Subject: SUSE 10.0 NVIDIA: how to enable 3D -- temporary conclusions --
==
I think the Linux support on Nvidia, is at best poor: hard to install,
often instable.

Also the Nvidia Linux drivers distribution model is unacceptable: I still
consider that when I purchase a computer peripheral for Linux, then I
should be able to use clean open source drivers for it.

I have purchased several NVIDIA cards, but unless NVIDIA wakes up and
provides a good alternative to the current situation... which has lasted a
long time, I will try ATI (or other video cards/chip vendor) in the
future, hoping that the situation is better there. (Not sure).

It is interesting to note that often new vendors establish a solid
presence in the Linux (and other open source)by providing what is missing.
I am wondering how many Laser printers did sell on the Linux market...
because others printers vendors had poor linux support.
My guess is "a lot ".

note: freely providing the technical product specification, API
(application programming interface) specification is what the open source
guys need to write device drivers.
Reverse engineering is possible, of course... but painful.
==
AnonymousFC4 wrote:

Hello:
boy, did I strike a cord with this posting !

my conclusions:

1) Other people seem to have similar issue, so it is real.

2) Since I downgraded the kernel, (to 2.6.13.5) I did not have a single
crash crash... and they where very frequent.
I did not enable 3D (but I did with SUSE 10 RC3 and had zero problems!

3) The kernel 2.6.13.5.7 may be OK but combined with the NVIDIA driver
there is a visible problem! Since we do not have access to the source
code of the driver, proper identitification is possible, but trickier.

4) I mildly disagree with the accusations of SUSE being lower quality,
SUSE 10.0 is overall excellent... but I would agree and reiterate that
SUSE/NOVELL should more focused on quality and testing, than only eyes
candy and marketing driven cosmetics "a la Microsoft".

Linux is supposed to be about substance, and the distro vendors will do
well to add value to Linux the smart way: add what is missing... like the
RPM manager (Red-Hat) or YAST (SUSE)... or trainings, documentation that
the hobbyists developing Linux don't care for.

5) The new business model (Open SUSE)is a good one, similar to Fedora,
but it fails on one point: proper integration and test of NON-GPL
software like NVIDIA device drivers, etc...

This should be easy to fix if SUSE does the proper "lobbying" to test and
release candidate of SUSE Linux, WITH THE INCLUSION of the non-gpl
stuff!. This includes ACROREAD, MP3 modules, etc....
Also large companies like NVIDIA could allow propre creations of distro
specific RPM's by releasing the "building blocks" even in some compiled
form, they also should amend their user's license to allow free
distribution!

We (users) should vote with our wallet by preferrately purchasing
hardware (here video cards) with open source software drivers...
How will NVIDIA, ATI and chip vendors achieve this? This is up to them!
There are many possible options.

6) The RTFM claim made here, by one posting has some validity... and some
sillyness in it: if I wanted to get in this mode, why should I use SUSE,
or RedHat, I will rather go Debian or derivatives (UBUNTU, possibly).

I have chosen SUSE Linux because I want to be user, not a hacker: my
expectation with it being a Linux Distro well documented, and simple to
use/update.
I would expect SUSE/NOVEL to make money by selling packages (less and
less), but books, training, and sopport.

7) The kids are still nagging...
At some point the kids will grow up and contribute, I am sure.

Thanks for all the posting, and contributions...
AFC4
====================
Roy L. Fuchs wrote:
On Sun, 25 Dec 2005 06:35:09 GMT, Andreas Gave
us: Roy L. Fuchs escribe:
If YOU would learn to READ the SUSE Linux Install HOW-TO on the
NVIDIA website, you would LEARN that the problem is YOU.
YOU as in [Y]ast [O]nline [u]pdate?
Wrong. "YOU" as in the person that posted the supposed "problem".


--
--John
to email, dial "usenet" and validate
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)
  #3  
Old December 28th 05, 07:39 AM posted to alt.comp.periphs.videocards.nvidia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Linux user: please support hardware vendors whith good Linux suppor.

In article , AnonymousFC4 says...
This is a repost: Original post on alt.os.linux.suse
Subject: SUSE 10.0 NVIDIA: how to enable 3D -- temporary conclusions --
==
I think the Linux support on Nvidia, is at best poor: hard to install, often
instable.

Is it ********? It's one of THE EASIEST to install.

Download .run file. sh .run file, folllow the bouncing ball. Edit X
config file and change a couple of well documented entries.


Also the Nvidia Linux drivers distribution model is unacceptable: I still
consider that when I purchase a computer peripheral for Linux, then I
should be able to use clean open source drivers for it.

Blame your open source friends for not writing one. If there's no open
source driver for a peripheral then there is only one group to blame -
the OSS community.

I have purchased several NVIDIA cards, but unless NVIDIA wakes up and
provides a good alternative to the current situation... which has lasted a
long time, I will try ATI (or other video cards/chip vendor) in the future,
hoping that the situation is better there. (Not sure).

ROFLMAO...than you'll have something to complain about.

It is interesting to note that often new vendors establish a solid presence
in the Linux (and other open source)by providing what is missing.
I am wondering how many Laser printers did sell on the Linux market...
because others printers vendors had poor linux support.
My guess is "a lot ".

Blame your OSS buddies.

note: freely providing the technical product specification, API (application
programming interface) specification is what the open source guys need to
write device drivers.


Why should a company that has spent $millions developing a product give
their information away for free?

--
Conor

I'm so grateful to the USA for their contribution to the war on terror.
After all, if they hadn't funded the IRA for 30 years, we wouldn't know
what terror was.
  #4  
Old December 28th 05, 02:00 PM posted to alt.comp.periphs.videocards.nvidia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Linux user: please support hardware vendors whith good Linux suppor.

Conor wrote:

In article , AnonymousFC4 says...
This is a repost: Original post on alt.os.linux.suse
Subject: SUSE 10.0 NVIDIA: how to enable 3D -- temporary conclusions --
==
I think the Linux support on Nvidia, is at best poor: hard to install,
often instable.

Is it ********? It's one of THE EASIEST to install.

Download .run file. sh .run file, folllow the bouncing ball. Edit X
config file and change a couple of well documented entries.


Also the Nvidia Linux drivers distribution model is unacceptable: I still
consider that when I purchase a computer peripheral for Linux, then I
should be able to use clean open source drivers for it.

Blame your open source friends for not writing one. If there's no open
source driver for a peripheral then there is only one group to blame -
the OSS community.


It's not that simple when the device has a complex proprietary interface.
If Nvidia and ATI would get it into their heads that the make _chips_ and
not _software_ and provided full documentation on their chips it would be a
different story, but reverse-engineering the damned things when all you
have to work with is the chip itself and a Windows driver in binary is a
collossal task.

I have purchased several NVIDIA cards, but unless NVIDIA wakes up and
provides a good alternative to the current situation... which has lasted
a long time, I will try ATI (or other video cards/chip vendor) in the
future, hoping that the situation is better there. (Not sure).

ROFLMAO...than you'll have something to complain about.

It is interesting to note that often new vendors establish a solid
presence in the Linux (and other open source)by providing what is
missing. I am wondering how many Laser printers did sell on the Linux
market... because others printers vendors had poor linux support.
My guess is "a lot ".

Blame your OSS buddies.


If you think it's easy, why don't _you_ do it?

note: freely providing the technical product specification, API
(application programming interface) specification is what the open source
guys need to write device drivers.


Why should a company that has spent $millions developing a product give
their information away for free?


So that they can make $millions actually selling products?

--
--John
to email, dial "usenet" and validate
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)
  #5  
Old December 28th 05, 10:38 PM posted to alt.comp.periphs.videocards.nvidia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Linux user: please support hardware vendors whith good Linux suppor.

"AnonymousFC4" wrote in message
...
I think the Linux support on Nvidia, is at best poor: hard to install,
often
instable.


Indeed, but that actually represents the best effort out of all the major
video chipset manufacturers.

Also the Nvidia Linux drivers distribution model is unacceptable: I still
consider that when I purchase a computer peripheral for Linux, then I
should be able to use clean open source drivers for it.


Most PC users do not share your opinion. It's also true that driver
development can cost more than hardware development, especially for
professional 3D CAD and DCC work. There are huge monetary investment and
trade secrets involved, so don't expect nVidia or ATi to release open-source
drivers.

I have purchased several NVIDIA cards, but unless NVIDIA wakes up and
provides a good alternative to the current situation... which has lasted a
long time, I will try ATI (or other video cards/chip vendor) in the
future,
hoping that the situation is better there. (Not sure).


ATi allocates driver development time commensurate with market share. This,
straight from the horse's mouth in an interview. Thus, there's one person
(out of some 50) dedicating half his time to Linux driver development... I
think Mac OS drivers receive higher priority.

It is interesting to note that often new vendors establish a solid
presence
in the Linux (and other open source)by providing what is missing.
I am wondering how many Laser printers did sell on the Linux market...
because others printers vendors had poor linux support.
My guess is "a lot ".


This has been said before, it's a chicken and egg thing. However, consider
this: both ATi and nVidia have pretty much abandoned the entire installed
base of AGP systems, as a conscious business decision. They certainly care
less about the Linux users.

--
"War is the continuation of politics by other means.
It can therefore be said that politics is war without
bloodshed while war is politics with bloodshed."


 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
good 64 bit linux distro and apps? a AMD x86-64 Processors 8 August 14th 05 08:47 PM
XP OEM - Interesting conversation with MS employee Michael C General 256 May 25th 05 10:52 PM
my new mobo o/c's great rockerrock Overclocking AMD Processors 10 June 30th 04 08:17 PM
Installing Ati Radeon 9700 drivers to Mandrake Linux 9.2 Meinz General Hardware 2 January 15th 04 06:09 PM
FAQ for alt.sys.pc-clone.packardbell, updated 02/02/97 . Packard Bell 1 August 26th 03 07:14 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:14 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2004-2018 ComputerBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.